Is Cry It Out Harmful? The Science of Stress

For years, the "Cry It Out" (CIO) method has been presented as a harmless, albeit difficult, path to better sleep.

Parents are often told that the stress of crying is short-lived and that the benefits of a full night’s rest outweigh the temporary distress.

However, as we delve deeper into the neurobiology of the infant brain, the question of "harm" becomes more nuanced.

It is not just about whether a child eventually sleeps; it is about what happens to their internal systems during the process.

In this article, we explore the science of stress and how prolonged, unsupported crying impacts a developing nervous system.

Understanding the Infant Stress Response

When an infant is left to cry in isolation, their body initiates a primitive survival response.

This is known as the "fight or flight" mechanism, governed by the sympathetic nervous system.

In this state, the brain perceives a threat to its survival—which, for an infant, is the absence of a protective caregiver.

The body immediately releases a surge of adrenaline and cortisol, the primary stress hormone.

While brief periods of stress are a natural part of development, the stress experienced during CIO is often "toxic" because it lacks a buffering presence.

Without a parent to co-regulate, the infant’s nervous system remains in a state of high alert for an extended period.

The Role of Cortisol in Brain Development

Cortisol is necessary for life, but in high doses, it can be neurotoxic to a developing brain.

During the first three years of life, the brain is growing at its most rapid rate, forming millions of neural connections every second.

High levels of cortisol can interfere with the development of the hippocampus, the area of the brain responsible for memory and emotional regulation.

It can also lead to an over-sensitization of the amygdala, which is the brain's "fear center."

Research indicates that infants who experience frequent, prolonged periods of unbuffered stress may develop a lower threshold for anxiety later in life.

According to the Harvard Center on the Developing Child, toxic stress can literally change the architecture of the brain.

Responsive parenting, conversely, acts as a biological "off switch" for the stress response.

By responding to a cry, we help the baby return to a state of homeostasis, or balance.

The Biological Reality of "Self-Soothing"

The most common justification for CIO is that it teaches "self-soothing."

However, as noted in our Holistic Science of Sleep Method, self-soothing is a developmental skill, not a learned behavior.

True self-soothing requires the prefrontal cortex to be mature enough to override the emotional centers of the brain.

In infants, this area of the brain is not yet developed.

When a baby "settles" themselves during a CIO session, they are not typically soothing; they are succumbing to learned helplessness.

This occurs when the brain determines that crying is a waste of vital energy because no response is coming.

The child enters a state of conservation-withdrawal, essentially shutting down to survive the perceived abandonment.

The Cortisol-Melatonin Conflict

Stress hormones do more than just cause emotional distress; they directly interfere with sleep chemistry.

Cortisol and melatonin (the sleep hormone) have an inverse relationship.

When cortisol is high, melatonin production is suppressed.

This is why many babies who undergo CIO often experience "early morning wakings" or become extremely difficult to settle for naps.

Their bodies are so flooded with stress hormones that they remain in a state of hyper-vigilance, making deep, restorative sleep harder to achieve.

To support healthy sleep, we must first lower the "total stress load" on the child's system.

Attachment and the Internal Working Model

Beyond the immediate biological impact, the science of stress touches on the foundation of attachment.

Attachment theory suggests that through our responses, we help children build an "Internal Working Model" of the world.

If a child’s cries are met with a consistent, warm response, they learn that the world is safe and that they are worthy of care.

If they are left to cry without a response, that model shifts toward insecurity and self-reliance at an age when they are biologically meant to be dependent.

Websites like Attachment Parenting International provide extensive research on how these early patterns influence adult relationships and mental health.

Choosing a responsive path ensures that sleep is never achieved at the expense of the child’s sense of safety.

The Impact on Parental Mental Health

We must also consider the stress of the parents during the CIO process.

Biological studies show that a mother's brain is literally "wired" to react to her baby's cry.

When a parent is told to ignore that cry, their own cortisol levels skyrocket.

This creates a "household of stress" where both the baby and the caregiver are in a state of dysregulation.

Long-term, this can lead to feelings of resentment, detachment, or increased postpartum anxiety.

At My Baby Sleep Consultant, we prioritize a "team-centric" approach that supports the parent's nervous system alongside the baby's.

We believe a calm parent is the best tool for a sleeping baby.

Moving Toward a Lower-Stress Approach

If you are concerned that CIO might be harmful or simply doesn't feel right, there is another way.

The goal of holistic sleep consulting is to minimize stress for the entire family.

Instead of forcing a baby to "deal with it," we investigate why they are crying.

Are they experiencing silent reflux or a food sensitivity?

Are they in a developmental leap that makes them feel vulnerable?\

By addressing the root cause, we can move toward better sleep while keeping the baby’s nervous system in a state of peace.

Resources like Mama Natural offer great insights into how holistic wellness supports these gentle transitions.

Conclusion

The science of stress tells us that infants are incredibly sensitive to the world around them.

While the "Cry It Out" method might result in a quiet nursery, the biological price can be high.

By choosing responsive, connection-based methods, we protect the child’s brain and emotional health.

Sleep is a biological function that thrives in an atmosphere of safety, not one of distress.

You can have both: a baby who sleeps well and a baby who feels deeply secure.

It starts with listening to the science, and more importantly, listening to your heart.

Ready to find a path to sleep that feels right for your family?

Protect your bond and your sleep...

Book a 15-minute Discovery Call to explore our non-CIO, science-based sleep plans.